Research › Which AI visibility tools the AI models recommend

Which AI visibility tools the AI models recommend

I asked four AI models 45 questions a marketing team asks when it wants to know how its brand shows up in AI answers. No question named a brand. Otterly was named in half of the 180 answers and Perplexity recommended a tool in 96% of its answers while Claude did so in 60%.

What I found

The chart is a discovery reading. It shows the share of the 180 answers that name each tool when the question asks which tool to use or buy and names no brand. Otterly and Peec AI and Profound lead and the long-established search tools follow some way behind. Semrush appears twice because the models name the company and its AI Visibility Toolkit as two different things.

The four models do not agree

The same 45 questions went to each model in the same words. Perplexity named at least one tool in 96% of its answers and Claude in 60%. The order of the tools also moves from model to model and a tool that one model names in a third of its answers another barely mentions. A brand that reads one model and calls it the AI view is reading one opinion.

Where the answers come from

Every answer was given with web search on and the pages it drew on were kept. Most of the pages cited are the tool vendors' own blogs and the comparison lists they publish and a few technology titles. The vendors that write the comparison pages are the vendors that get named. Gemini's citations arrive as redirect links that do not name the site and they are left out of this chart so it reads three models and not four.

What this means for a company

A model with search on does not weigh a brand's own page against a rival's. It reads a handful of comparison pages and repeats what they say. The brand that is named is the one that appears on those pages and the brand that wrote them is named most of all. For a company that wants to be in the answer the work is the pages the models read and not the home page.

This is one reading on one day and so it is an observation. It becomes a finding when the next reading repeats it. My details are on the contact page if you have asked the same questions and found something different.